Church Guy Tony and Replicating His Look

In April 1980 I took photos for a church-based theater group of their full costume rehearsal for a presentation they were giving. Trinity Episcopal Church in Hartford. This shot of Tony has always been a favorite photo of mine. Interestingly, there really was only one shot of him that was clearly the best expression and pose. Could I recreate that same lighting and similar expression of myself? It was an interesting challenge, and fun at the same time. Photoshop provided the sizing, selection, and color matching, but only after I matched the lighting and camera angle in the studio. Happy Easter today!